We went through at least 25 suggestions, and this one seemed to resonate the most. Many others were usable, and we will be using them (and automatically granting points to the person who suggested it) in future contests.
Here is your #400 contest:
The Philadelphia Cricket Club is the oldest country club in the United States.
Founded in 1854, the main sport here was cricket initially, but golf and tennis quickly became primary. The cricket league was disbanded in 1929, but revived in 1998, and has become quite popular here.
Those who batted a century before being dismissed included:
and those who needed an extra: